It received a Mint 9 grading, which is the second best it can be, and while no details about why it was rated as such its reasonable to think that it might have been slightly damaged inside of its packaging, but theres plenty of options to why its not perfect
This is especially true in cEDH, where this card looks like an absolute slam-dunk
Shiny rares give many of the non-ex Pokemon a fresh coat of paint
Bhaal, Lord of Murder is more or less an Odric's Outrider in the command zone, but that it only counts for nontoken creatures means you can't combo with Scurry Oak, so it's probably not that great
Things like holograms and new borders are fine stop-gaps, but counterfeiting Magic cards is so lucrative that it's worth the time and effort for the producers of fake cards to figure out ways around these security measures
Finally, Esikas Chariot only makes a single Cat token in Alchemy, so its much less of a problem on turn four